|
Institutions need to strike
a balance between achieving academic goals and fulfilling the industry’s
needs: Prof Jamadagni, Chairman, CEDT, IISc
Bangalore, May 17, 2001
The
Centre for Electronics Design and Technology (CEDT) at the Indian Institute
of Science, Bangalore (India), was established in 1974 with the joint support
of the Department of Electronics (DoE), Ministry of Education, University
Grants Commission and Swiss Development Co-operation of the Government
of Switzerland. CEDT offers a post-graduate Degree programme, M Tech. in
Electronic Design and Technology, research programmes leading to MSc (Engg)
and Ph D.
CEDT maintains close links with the
industries through joint and consultancy projects; experts from the industry
are formally associated with the Centre. Besides, it also conducts
joint workshops to understand their requirements and to benefit from their
experience in order to keep the activities of CEDT relevant in the Indian
context.
indiamarkets spoke to Prof
Jamadagni, Chairman, CEDT, to know more about the department and its relevance
in industry circle.
indiamarkets: Product development
is on CEDT’s top priority list. Can you let us know how many products really
make their way to the market?
Prof Jamadagni: Our primary
focus is not on launching products. It is rather on preparing good
product designers. First of all, you should ask how many of our product
designers make it to top-notch companies that are involved in making products
and introducing them into the market. That would be the first bench. I
would say that all the students who pass out from here are involved in
product design either as entrepreneurs or working with the industry. There
is a good demand for those who pass out with M.Tech from here. They are
all involved without exception in product designing. There is always a
small percentage that pursues doctoral studies. I would say all the students
are our primary products. They are all involved and contributing towards
product design in one way or the other.
Secondly, one should remember that
making products is not the business of any institution. We are not in the
thick of the market. There are many factors involved in launching a product.
Student projects’ is just the first step. Companies suggest the product
and we create the concept. The companies build on the concept and develop
the product. In other words, most of the companies use institutions as
a ground where they can test out what you can call as proof of concept.
They would then further develop the product.
If you go by that norm, that is the
number of proofs of concept that we have done, it would be close to 30-40
per cent. Each year, we take up about 10-15 projects. At least, three-four
of them make their way to the market. When it reaches the market, you may
not be able to make out the relation between the product and what we did
here. It will have gone through various stages of research and development
at the industry level.
A majority of our product designers
(say 80 per cent) stay back here in India.
indiamarkets: How closely
does CEDT interact with the industry?
Also please tell us about the industry
consultancy services that CEDT offers.
Prof Jamadagni: I would say
that every activity in this department is centred around the industry.
All our M Tech projects are industry-sponsored. I would say that there
is hardly any activity here which is not industry-related.
indiamarkets: Why is it that most
of the Indian institutions are running toward the industry, especially
in the recent past? Is it for raising funds?
Prof Jamadagni: Funding from the
government has dwindled and we need to depend on the industry for funding.
Raising funds is certainly important. But that is secondary. Our priority
is to increase the relevance of our department in catering to the industry.
More than the funding, the quality and the name of the institute is important
to us. Now that we have become market-driven, the way I (department) am
known in the market is how good our students are. There needs to be a balance
between achieving academic goals and fulfilling what the industry requires.
At times, it is risky to maintain this balance.
A new component that most of the
institutions in India have started exploring is how all the teaching, research
and development carried out in the department can be translated so as to
benefit individuals, society and the university. So there is a trend now
to create companies. It is more than an incubation centre where the department
or the institute has an equity participation in the company. In the long
term, the institute also benefits by acquiring Intellectual Property Rights
over the developed products.
indiamarkets: As an individual,
how have you built the brand of CEDT in the industry circles?
Prof Jamadagni: It is the
department and I am one of the individuals in the department. We work on
many projects in collaboration with either the industry or an educational
institution. While working with them, we try to build partnerships rather
than having a `big brother’ attitude.
Most of the people in this country
lack in discipline and teamwork. As long as we do well in these two arenas,
there is no problem.
indiamarkets: Please tell
us about the projects the department is working on at present
Prof Jamadagni: There are
two broad groups of projects: Educational projects and product-oriented
research projects.
We have a large number of educational
projects, which are funded by the government. We participate in a very
significant and aggressive manner in these projects. For example, we participated
in Project IMPACT aimed at improving the quality of education in computers
and electronics at the engineering college and polytechnic levels. It was
a national project with about 40 institutions involved and a financial
outlay of $ 28 million. It is funded by the World Bank and cofinanced by
Swiss Development Co-operation, and co-ordinated by the Department of Electronics
of the Government of India. The Indian Institute of Science was one
of the five Resource Centres, where the project was coordinated by the
faculty from CEDT.
There are two projects: self-sustainability
and VLSI program, which are funded by the ministry of information technology.
The non-educational, product-oriented
research projects are funded by the industry. There is a project called
project Network, which is funded by Cisco.
Each year, we conduct an annual product
exhibition of M Tech Student Projects called the ‘CEDT Design EXPO’. In
this exposition, there is a live demonstration of the prototype electronic
products developed by the department. This effort is to bring industry
and academicians closer to CEDT. The annual exposition is a culmination
of the efforts of students and faculty of CEDT in realising a working
prototype model.
indiamarkets: Can you throw
light on the ‘Design Desk’ that the department is planning to set up? When
will this materialise?
Prof Jamadagni: CEDT is setting
up ‘Design Desk’, a web-based tool, which will offer electronics designers
information and tips in a number of application areas. The tool provides
CEDT's tried and proven designs. We would for instance have designs
and PCB layout around specific DSPs. For somebody designing with a particular
DSP, much of the design work will have already been done. If you are designing
an add-on card, the DSP chip, memory, and I/O will be up there, and if
you want to add an I/O for a specific application, you just add that and
redo the layout.
We have implemented this idea in
one or two areas. We have not progressed as much as we have liked to. One
of the reasons for this is lack of funding, specifically for this concept.
We need a large number of people. If we find more people, we will certainly
progress more. We are putting our best efforts. Probably in the next one
or two years, we will see more things happening on this front.
indiamarkets: What are the
challenges that the academia faces while interacting with the industry
or collaborating for the development of a product?
Prof Jamadagni: There are
two main aspects. First of all, when you work with the industry, there
are issues related to intellectual property of the product. When we work
with a number of companies, every company would like to be guaranteed that
what I do for X will not be revealed to his rival. One of the primary challenges
that we have in a university is to convey this confidence to the industry
and that is a challenge
The second aspect is of timeliness.
For the industry, product cycle time is very important. Very often, the
university cycle time does not suit them. In order to overcome this drawback,
two groups will handle every project. First, the students work on the project
during the course of their career. The inputs from the students’ project
are then taken by another group that will look at the rest of the thing.
indiamarkets: Apart from the
IT industry, the US slowdown has had its impact on the US semiconductor
industry also. How do you see the Indian semiconductor industry being affected
by this?
Prof Jamadagni: The semiconductor
industry in India has a minimal presence. It is limited only to design.
No fabrication takes place in India. From what I observe from the enquiries
I get and the number of people whom I meet, there does not seem to be any
problem about silicon design. They see that the cost of designing is lower
here and orders are indeed still coming. Design work on this front is on.
There is nothing to worry about.
I am told that bookings of companies
like TSMC and United Microelectronics Corporation (UMC) who manufacture
most of the chips in the world have come down a little bit during the last
couple of months. Everyone hopes that this is a short-lived phenomenon.
Certainly the impact is not as big as that in IT industry. The electronics
product industry and silicon design industry seem to be reasonably better-off.
Yes, certainly the companies have
become more cautious of their movements. Among the companies we interact
with, there are four to five companies that have in their minds products
to launch over the next two years. There are companies that deliver consumer
electronic goods. Earlier, they would approach other design companies for
chip design. Having burnt their fingers, they now want to set up their
own little design house, either in the US or in India. There are companies
that are investing now and making a fresh dive into this field. All these
indicate that the impact of the slowdown in the US economy is not affecting
the Indian semiconductor industry to a large extent.
The interviewer Pradeep B S, can
be contacted at pradeep@indiamarkets.com
|